Friday 27 July 2018

McNaughton




Fantasy: The faculty of imagining impossible or improbable things


Reality: The state of things as they actually exist



Being Human (Fantasy+Reality)

Fantasy entertains the emotions 

Reality entertains the logic 


Fantasy (Emotions) cannot overcome Reality (Logic)

Only Logic overcomes Emotions



Example: Love (Fantasy Vs Reality)




Insanity: Fantasy cannot overcome Reality 



McNaughton: Guide To Insanity




The Story Of Daniel McNaughten




Prior to McNaughton rules there was no clear set way of dealing with the insane

McNaughton rules: Grounds for Insanity 



McNaughten rules since 1843 has been modified over the course of time




Insanity Pleas: Remembering McNaughten

Burden of proof is on the defendant 






Snapshot


Fantasy VS Reality

Reality driven by Logic

Fantasy driven by Emotions

Logic > Emotions


Insanity: Fantasy cannot overcome Reality
























No comments:

Post a Comment